Agatha's second act? The awards season push that might hint at more seasons to come for Agatha All Along

Recent awards season has conjured up new questions regarding the future of Agatha All Along. While we ponder what delights this ghostly version of her might bring about, the word out there is that Disney+ submitted the show in the comedy categories! Did you see that coming? I surely did not. While Agatha’s tone was one of dark humor, this move feels like Marvel might be hinting at a possible encore for Kathryn Hahn to present us with new chapters of Agatha Harkness’ stories.

Comedy? Why? Let’s be honest: while Agatha is no Deadpool, and the body count is high for such a short series, the show has a unique balance, a well-glued blend of dark mysticism and an edge of humor, which is central to the show, serving fans with a delightful taste of something refreshingly different. No big ”let’s save the world.” More like “save yourself… if you can.”

And in Agatha’s road trip (pun intended!), we witnessed Disney taking on once-risky territory. Through her relationship with Rio, Billy’s journey as a proudly queer character, and even Agatha appearing nude in the very first episode, it became clear that the show wasn’t afraid to push boundaries. So, the biggest question now is: what other bold moves could be brewing in this cauldron of witches?

Strategic move or just witchy business?

Of course, this could mean that Disney+ is subtly nodding toward a potential second season. Do you also think that Marvel is more than hinting that Agatha’s story isn’t over yet? I do.

Marvel’s dance around the rules for miniseries only adds to the mystery, since they need to prove that this character arc has more life. As the first true character study of an antiheroine within the MCU, Agatha All Along dives into darker, funnier territory that no other Marvel series has ventured into, and, while Agatha’s magic is captivating, the show itself breaks new ground by entering into uncharted territory. Well, for Disney anyway.

Why does that matter? Because Agatha’s connection with Rio and Billy is a refreshing leap into real, layered queerness that rarely makes it into mainstream stories. Billy’s presence also breaks norms, letting young queer identities be part of a magical world that doesn’t reduce them to stereotypes. Marvel is slowly exploring real identities and relationships, taking Agatha All Along beyond fantasy and placing it in a space that feels authentic.

An awards race against heavy hitters

So how does Agatha All Along hold up against TV’s comedy giants? Placing Agatha All Along in the comedy realm pits Kathryn Hahn against some of TV’s most celebrated comedians: Jean Smart in Hacks, Quinta Brunson in Abbott Elementary, and Ayo Edebiri in The Bear. Each of these shows has its own brand of humor, but Agatha’s mix of wit and wickedness stands out, making Hahn’s character a rare gem in the comedy lineup. This awards season, Hahn has a unique chance to break into the Golden Globes for the first time and potentially add another Emmy nod to her career.

Isn’t it refreshing to see a Marvel character who doesn’t fit the “save the day” mold? Hahn’s Agatha doesn’t conform to that script. Instead, she mixes magic, sass, and queerness with that delicious question mark: will she do something “good,” or is she just having fun? Marvel’s being coy, keeping fans on their toes—but we’re here for it.

This submission also highlights a growing trend in the MCU: morally complex characters who pull us in without the usual “hero’s journey” arc. Agatha and her morally grey charm fit right in, defying expectations and leaving room for layers. She’s the antiheroine we can’t help but root for, even when we shouldn’t. But why do we root for her? With her flaws and that smirk, what is it about Agatha that makes her so fascinating?

Beyond spells and hexes: Could Agatha’s legacy last?

And then there’s the biggest question of all: does this mean Agatha is here to stay? As Marvel dives into richer character studies, Agatha All Along might be paving the way for a whole new era—one where magic, humor, and queerness blend seamlessly. Agatha’s charisma, humor, and complexity feel like magic cast to last, capturing fans, critics, and maybe even the Television Academy under her spell.

If there’s one thing Agatha’s awards season submission tells us, it’s this: the story might just be starting. Disney and Marvel are keeping their cards close, but Hahn’s Agatha has already shown she’s worth every nomination—and maybe even another season to spread more of her chaotic, queer, and captivating charm.